The Account Planning Group has done a fascinating survey on how planners are feeling right now.
It's really worth a look to make up your own mind, but what struck me was the fact that nearly one 1 in 3 are less than sure they want to continue as a planner post-pandemic.
I couldn't tell you if this is higher than this time last year, or if they want to remain a strategy type, just not in agencies, however this is still worrying.
There will be many reasons why, we re-appraise everything in big turning points – we're living in the mother of turning points right now.
Naturally, intelligent, curious people will wonder what else it out there at times like these.
They'll also get some fresh perspective to decide, is it really worth it? The uncertainty that comes with your agency always being three phone calls away from oblivion. Avoiding burnout from the long hours the job sometimes demands. Keeping going when planners often don't feel valued and need to constantly justify their very existence in a way creatives, suits and others do not.
Agencies have always had open bars (phrase stolen from the survey) for planners to a certain degree.
Wearing what you like, being around colourful people, work that is genuinely interesting and varied. That felt more than worth it when most other jobs meant wearing suits, conforming to corporate rules and generally 'working for the man'. Agencies felt like a rare place where curious, thoughtful people who loved solving puzzles, yet also really enjoyed being creative could flourish.
The trade off between the interestingness and the downsides will seem less attractive to many these days.
The immediate context is that when you enjoy sparking off a team and being part of a great culture (although this isn't all agencies anyway, many with the grooviest clothes and best designed offices are the most conservative and, in many cases, more intimidating than the Devil Wears Prada), it's worth it.
You don't get that from endless Zoom meetings.
There are longer term issues at play here too though.
In recent years, corporate life has become, well, less corporate and more progressive. More relaxed clothes, more relaxed culture, better work life balance, much better at mental health – better than agencies I'd wager.
It has also remained relatively secure while agency life has felt more tenuous. After talking to a few planners who work in house, they also seem to feel more appreciated and able to do purer work, because they don't have to then sell it in, or post rationalise something a creative has had in there drawer for few years.
No wonder there is a slow creep of client companies taking planning in house, no wonder planners are wondering, is all there is?
The clear theme is that modern employees want autonomy (sense of freedom in their role), mastery (the chance to get better at their discipline) and belonging (part of something bigger than them that they believe in).
If you run an agency, or a planning department, read the survey and ask yourself, do your people really get this?
Do they really feel valued or are they required to conform to that necessary evil cliche?
Do they get the freedom to push things, or are they trapped by proprietary process, constricted by micromanaging suits or even cowered by a rampant creative department?
Most importantly, do they feel they belong? Can they believe in your agency and the work it does? Does your culture really feel that good or is just a corporate sweatshop with better coffee and a few beanbags?
Even more importantly, ask yourself do you care? These are curious people who want to feel stimulated and valued. If you don't value your planning team, it's increasingly likely they'll escape the open cage to somewhere that will – and it may be your clients.
Planning is a fantastic job, done by fantastic people, I think its one of the best jobs in the world and more interesting than ever right now- I hope agencies try and hold on to the people that do it before it's too late.
Right now, many companies known for performance marketing are betting on brand, there's the conflict between long and short term, the demand for creativity for way more than creative work. Every rule in the book is up for grabs now that COVID has shattered any semblance of the status quo, while for years before the pandemic, media was fragmenting, culture was getting faster and more porous and nothing seemed certain.
There has never been a better time for planners to add value, but first you have to value them.